Brooklyn Pizza is temporarily closed due to the Storm on 5/10.
We will resume orders in a few weeks. Thanks for your support of Brooklyn Pizza.

Craving Authenticity?

Classic New York-Style Pizza for Pick Up or Delivery in Tallahassee, FL

Pick Up & Delivery

Recommended by Florida State University

AUTHENTIC – Our New York-style pizza has been authenticated by true New yorkers.
WELCOMING – Whether you’re dining in or ordering online, you’ll always receive friendly service.
LOCAL – We’ve been a local staple in Tallahassee, Florida for almost 20 years.

Enjoy Authentic Pizza

Visit our New York pizza restaurant in Tallahassee, FL

If you want the real deal, Brooklyn Pizza is the New York pizza restaurant for you. Our pizza has been authenticated by real New Yorkers. What can we say, we’re picky about what we make! When you visit us, you’ll get a great meal each and every time. Plus, we offer convenient pizza delivery services in Tallahassee, FL.

You’ve got to try this restaurant – we promise you’ll want to come back. Stop by tonight for a fantastic meal – try some of our pizza, calzones, pepperoni rolls, cheese knots or stombolis!

Mon-Sun: 11:00AM-11:00PM

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Brooklyn Pizza has online ordering through Foodies Takeout and Delivery.

Brooklyn Pizza does offer delivery.

Yes, Brooklyn Pizza has curbside pickup service available.

Brooklyn Pizza is located at 2035 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304.

Store Hours:

Monday – Sunday: 11:00AM – 11:00PM

Brooklyn Pizza closes at 11:00 PM every day. Closing hours are subject to change.

Brooklyn Pizza opens at 11:00 AM every day. Opening hours are subject to change.

Currently, Brooklyn Pizza plans to be open on Sunday from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM for Delivery and Pickup. These hours are subject to change so be sure to check back from time to time.

Brooklyn Pizza is currently offering deals. View the menu to see what deals are available.

Brooklyn Pizza makes pizza, calzones, pepperoni rolls, cheese knots, stombolis and more!

Yes, Brooklyn Pizza has a variety of chicken wings served with bleu cheese dressing or ranch.

Yes, Brooklyn Pizza has vegetarian pizza but does not currently have any vegan pizza options.

Yes, Brooklyn pizza has gluten free pizza options available.

We specialize in New York Style pizza and some would call it thin crust, but we think it’s perfect. We also have a Sicilian pizza with a thicker crust on the menu.