(850) 224-5454 | Brooklyn Pizza | Mon-Sun: 10:30AM-11:00PM

Craving Authenticity?

Get Classic New York-Style Pizza for Pick-up or Delivery in Tallahassee, FL

We are following necessary covid guidelines like social distancing, sanitizing menus and common touch places, etc..



Share-It Nights

We’d Love to Work With You

Ask How Our Restaurant Can Help You Raise Money

Make Us Your Go-to Local Restaurant

Everyone needs a favorite local restaurant. If you live in the Tallahassee, FL area, Brooklyn Pizza is a great choice. Here, you can:

Get delicious and convenient restaurant catering
Order your favorite New York-style pizzas or chicken wings
Partner with a charitable restaurant for your fundraiser

Discover Why Our Customers Keep Coming Back

It’s one thing to have customers, but it’s another to have regulars. You’ll find our New York pizza restaurant packed with regulars almost every night of the week. Brooklyn Pizza is:

Authentic – our New York-style pizza has been authenticated by true New Yorkers
Welcoming – whether you’re dining in or ordering pizza delivery, you’ll always receive friendly service
Local – we’ve been a local staple in Tallahassee, FL for almost 20 years

Not in the mood for the best pizza in town? We’re also known for our fresh chicken wings. Seriously, they’re hot out of the fryer!

Welcome Students For Fall Semester.


Jessica Rivera

Awesome pizza!! And the owner is just so nice! Definitely will be back! 5 stars!


Mahmoud Abdelhadi

The pizza is Amazing, and the service is fabulous, I have been always a big fan of the quality of this place


Dawson Hulme

Pretty okay! Solid choice, and pro tip — get the cheesy garlic knots.

Enjoy Authentic Pizza

Visit our New York pizza restaurant in Tallahassee, FL

If you want the real deal, Brooklyn Pizza is the New York pizza restaurant for you. Our pizza has been authenticated by real New Yorkers. What can we say, we’re picky about what we make! When you visit us, you’ll get a great meal each and every time. Plus, we offer convenient pizza delivery services in Tallahassee, FL.

You’ve got to try this restaurant – we promise you’ll want to come back. Stop by tonight for a fantastic meal – try some of our pizza, calzones, pepperoni rolls, cheese knots or stombolis!

Brooklyn Pizza

2035 West Pensacola Street
Tallahassee, FL 32304

Call Us

(850) 224-5454

Brooklyn Pizza

Mon: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Tue: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Wed: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Thu: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Fri: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Sat: 10:30AM-11:00PM
Sun: 10:30AM-11:00PM